| * | Carlos J. Alonso, 2007–Jan. 2011 |
| Charles Altieri, 2006–09 |
| K. Anthony Appiah, 2003–06 |
| * | Jonathan Arac, 2010–Jan. 2014 |
| * | Sara Scott Armengot, 2008–Jan. 2012 |
| David Bartholomae, 1998–2001 |
| Dorian F. Bell, 2006–09 |
| * | Russell A. Berman, 2009–Jan. 2011 (VP), Jan. 2011–Jan. 2012 (P) |
| * | Michael Bérubé, 2002–05, 2010–Jan. 2012 (VP), Jan. 2012–Jan. 2013 (P) |
| Peter Brooks, 1994–97 |
| * | Lawrence I. Buell, 2010–Jan. 2014 |
| Judith Butler, 2001–04 |
| Rey Chow, 2001–04 |
| Kirsten M. Christensen, 1998–2001 |
| * | Jennifer Crewe, 2009–Jan. 2013 |
| Reed Way Dasenbrock, 2000–03 |
| Heather Dubrow, 1996–99 |
| * | Rosemary G. Feal, 2002– (Exec. Dir.) |
| Margaret W. Ferguson, 1997–2000 |
| Frances Smith Foster, 1995–98 |
| Phyllis Franklin, 1985–2002 (Exec. Dir.) |
| Marilyn Gaddis Rose, 2004–07 |
| Anne Ruggles Gere, 2006–09 |
| Sandra M. Gilbert, 1981–84, 1994–95 (VP), 1996 (P) |
| Gerald Graff, 1990–93, 2006–07 (VP), 2008 (P) |
| Stephen Greenblatt, 1991–94, 2000–01 (VP), 2002 (P) |
| Roland Greene, 1999–2002 |
| John Guillory, 2004–07 |
| * | Jane Harper, 2007–Jan. 2011 |
| * | Dorothea Heitsch, 2010–Jan. 2014 |
| Peter Uwe Hohendahl, 1995–98 |
| Michael Holquist, 1991–94, 2005–06 (VP), 2007 (P) |
| Linda Hutcheon, 1993–96, 1998–99 (VP), 2000 (P) |
| * | Francis Abiola Irele, 2007–Jan. 2011 |
| Susan Kirkpatrick, 1993–96 |
| Mary N. Layoun, 2005–08 |
| * | George Levine, 2008–Jan. 2012 |
| Herbert Lindenberger, 1995–96 (VP), 1997 (P) |
| Françoise Lionnet, 1999–2002 |
| Andrea A. Lunsford, 1994–97 |
| Yolanda Martínez–San Miguel, 2004–07 |
| Nancy K. Miller, 2002–05 |
| Sylvia Molloy, 1994–97, 1999–2000 (VP), 2001 (P) |
| Elisabeth Mudimbe-Boyi, 2003–06 |
| Cary Nelson, 1999–2002 |
| Susan Noakes, 1994–97 |
| * | Richard M. Ohmann, 2010–Jan. 2014 |
| Marjorie Perloff, 2004–05 (VP), 2006 (P) |
| Catherine Porter, 1996–99, 2007–08 (VP), 2009 (P) |
| Mary Louise Pratt, 1985–88, 2001–02 (VP), 2003 (P) |
| Paula Rabinowitz, 2006–09 |
| Tey Diana Rebolledo, 2001–04 |
| A. LaVonne Brown Ruoff, 2002–05 |
| * | Karin C. Ryding, 2009–Jan. 2013 |
| Edward W. Said, 1997–98 (VP), 1999 (P) |
| Rosaura Sánchez, 2003–04 |
| Amada Sandoval, 2002–05 |
| Robert Scholes, 1997–2000, 2002–03 (VP), 2004 (P) |
| Rosemarie Scullion, 2000–03 |
| Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick, 1996–98 |
| Elaine Showalter, 1989–92, 1996–97 (VP), 1998 (P) |
| Nicolas Shumway, 2005–06 |
| * | Sidonie Smith, 2000–03, 2008–09 (VP), 2010–Jan. 2011 (P) |
| Hortense J. Spillers, 2005–08 |
| Domna C. Stanton, 1989–92, 2003–04 (VP), 2005 (P) |
| Guy Stern, 2004–07 |
| Susan Rubin Suleiman, 1993–96 |
| Eric J. Sundquist, 1996–99 |
| * | Lynne Tatlock, 2008–Jan. 2012 |
| Frank Trommler, 1995–98 |
| Katie Trumpener, 2000–03 |
| Priscilla Wald, 2005–08 |
| * | Alexandra K. Wettlaufer, 2008–Jan. 2012 |
| Virginia Wright Wexman, 1998–2001 |
| * | Kathleen Woodward, 2009–Jan. 2013 |
| Anthony C. Yu, 1998–2001 |
| George Yúdice, 1997–2000 |
